When Is It Too Soon to Rehome a Dog You Can Not Handle?

Deciding to rehome a dog is not an easy decision. For many pet parents, it comes with guilt, heartbreak, and a whole lot of second-guessing. Is this the right thing to do? Could things get better? The reality is that most dogs need time to adjust to a new home — weeks, even months. It’s completely normal for the first few days (or longer) to feel rough.

But sometimes, despite our best efforts, a dog’s needs go beyond what we can provide. Whether you are considering rehoming due to time, finances, behavior, health, or life changes, finding a safe, suitable new home may be the most loving and responsible choice for both you and your dog. Before you make any final calls, we will help you figure out what’s typical, what’s not, and how long to wait before considering rehoming.

TL;DR: Before you rehome, give the dog at least three months to adjust. Be sure to also exhaust other options, such as working with professional dog trainers or behaviorists, or addressing potential medical issues that may be causing problematic behaviors.

How soon is too soon to rehome?

This is one of the biggest questions new pet parents ask when they’re feeling overwhelmed — and for good reason. The truth is, most dogs need time to settle into a new home. The stress of a new environment and new experiences can make even the most seemingly emotionally stable dog anxious, aloof, or fearful at first.

There’s a general guideline that trainers and behaviorists use to help pet parents understand how long it takes for a dog to adjust to a new home and for their true personality to shine through. (Although some may take a bit longer, other pups might adjust quicker.)

• Give them three days to decompress from the stress of a shelter or previous home.

• It may take them three weeks to learn the household routine.

• Expect three months to pass before they feel fully comfortable in your home and bonded to you.

Of course, this doesn’t mean you’re locked in for three months, no matter what. It just means that big changes take time. Behavioral issues — such as whining, hiding, or even accidents — can be part of that normal adjustment period. During that time, you’ll help them adjust by providing routines and starting some basic training to forge a stronger bond.

When is it best to consider rehoming sooner? 

If there’s a real safety issue — such as severe aggression towards people or pets — it’s reasonable to contact the shelter or rescue they came from, and ask them to connect you to a pro. Likewise, if your life circumstances change dramatically and you can no longer provide for your dog’s basic needs, that’s different than just exercising more patience.

But if it’s not an emergency, give your dog some time, structure, and support. Often, what feels overwhelming on day five looks completely different on day 30.

Common reasons for rehoming a dog

Pet parents choose to rehome their dog for many reasons. Although each situation is unique, there are some common reasons people face this tough decision. From unexpected behavior challenges to major life changes to financial stressors, understanding the “why” can take away some of the stigma and remind pet parents that needing to rehome a dog doesn’t mean they no longer love their dog. 

Conflict between pets

Conflict between pets can be a major stressor for families. Many pet parents bring home a new dog or cat, expecting them to become friends (or at least peacefully co-exist) with an existing pet. When that doesn’t happen, daily life can become chaotic and emotionally draining. 

Research shows that nearly 28 percent of returned adoptions are due to issues between a new pet and the existing pets — or children — in the home. In some cases, despite training and careful management of pets, the conflict may pose safety risks or create an unmanageable environment, forcing a family to rehome their dog.

What can help? Slow introductions between pets are key. Keep them separated at first, swap scents, and take plenty of time before having them meet while unleashed.

Related article

How Can I Stop My Dogs From Fighting?

Consider this your guide to keeping the peace in your home, from spotting conflicts between your dogs to stopping them and preventing them in the first place.

The time commitment

Time commitment is one of the most underestimated parts of becoming a pet parent and a common reason some dogs are rehomed. Between exercise, training, grooming, and daily care, dogs require consistent time and attention to thrive. For many pet parents, busy work schedules, family demands, or unexpected life changes can make it difficult to provide the level of care their dog needs. 

If a dog’s needs for physical activity, mental stimulation, and companionship aren’t met, this can lead to behavior problems, stress for the pet, and guilt for pet parents. In these situations, a dog may be rehomed to ensure they get the time and attention they deserve.

What can help? Setting up a schedule can help keep things running smoothly.

Related article

Your Dog Wants a Routine. Here’s How to Build One.

Healthy habits to build with your new dog, plus how to create a schedule that works for both of you.

Stress on finances

Financial strain is another common reason for rehoming a pet. The cost of food, veterinary care, grooming, training, and unexpected medical emergencies can quickly add up, sometimes exceeding what pet parents can reasonably afford. 

Studies have found that financial limitations are among the leading reasons for pet relinquishment, often ranking alongside time and housing challenges. For some, these expenses create ongoing stress or force impossible choices between a pet’s needs and other essential household costs. 

What can help? Pet insurance, setting up a budget for pet costs, and getting help from community services can put you on the right track.

Related article

Vet Bill Assistance: Get Help with Vet Bills

Dealing with high vet bills? See assistance options for affordable pet care. Get the support your pet needs without breaking the bank.

Behavior problems

Nearly half of pet parents say concerns over behavior problems are why they rehomed a dog. Challenges such as aggression, anxiety, destructive behaviors, or difficulty with training can leave a pet parent feeling overwhelmed and unsure of how to keep their dog at home. 

Although some behaviors can be improved with training, management, and professional support, some families simply do not have the time, finances, or resources to commit to resolving behavioral issues. 

What can help? Consult with your veterinarian or a trainer, or connect with the shelter or rescue you adopted your dog from to get tips on low-cost behavior advice.

Related article

Yes, You Can Train a Dog with Behavioral Issues

Some dogs just need a bit of training and encouragement to help them overcome undesired behaviors.

Change in life circumstances

Changes in life circumstances are common and often unavoidable. Events such as moving to a new home, changes in work schedules, growing families, health issues, or financial shifts can impact a family’s ability to care for a pet. These transitions may make it difficult to provide the time, space, or resources a dog needs to thrive. Although heartbreaking, rehoming in these situations can ensure the dog lives in a more stable environment.

What can help? Look for short-term solutions before making a permanent choice. This could mean asking friends or family for help, hiring a dog walker, or getting a temporary foster through local rescues.

Related article

Renting With Pets: What to Know Before You Sign a Lease

Considering renting with pets? Read more to learn about renter policies and how to navigate them.

Health problems

Whether impacting the pet parent or the dog, health problems can be a significant factor in rehoming a pet. When a family member faces illness, disability, or other medical challenges, the time, energy, and resources required to care for a dog may no longer be feasible. 

Similarly, dogs with chronic health conditions or costly medical needs can place a heavy burden on their families. In these situations, rehoming can provide a way to ensure the dog receives the care they deserve, in a setting better equipped to support them physically, emotionally, and mentally. 

What can help? Explore financial assistance programs through veterinary schools, nonprofits, or local shelters. Some vets offer payment plans or low-cost clinics.

Related article

The Ultimate Guide to Pet Health Checkups

Regular vet visits are key to keeping your pet healthy. Here’s what happens during a checkup, when to get them, and what to bring.

Tips to consider before rehoming

Choosing to rehome a dog is one of the hardest decisions a pet parent can make. It’s a deeply personal choice made out of love and a desire to give your dog the best life possible, even when it means saying goodbye. Taking time to consider your dog’s needs, your circumstances, and the resources available to both of you can lead to the best outcome for everyone involved. When rehoming a dog, it’s important to consider the following.

• Consider your current life circumstances: Can you provide your dog with the emotional, physical, and mental needs they require to thrive and live with you happily?

• Ask for help and support from your community: Sometimes friends and family members are willing to help support you in caring for your dog, either physically or financially. 

• Seek out a professional: Whether you are struggling with behavioral issues or you need some support through doggy daycare or pet sitting, a professional can help meet a variety of your dog’s needs.

• Use community-run resources: If you are struggling financially and need medical support or food for your dog, consider pet pantries and low-cost vet clinics. Many cities offer low-cost or free resources to help pet parents keep their dogs. 

How to rehome a dog fast

When circumstances change quickly, some pet parents find themselves needing to rehome their dog as soon as possible. While this can feel overwhelming and difficult depending on their specific needs, there are safe and responsible ways to find a new home quickly without compromising your dog’s well-being.

Rehoming a dog websites

Using a reputable dog-rehoming website is an effective way to find your pet a new home, while staying involved in the process. These platforms help you find a family that’s a good match through a detailed profile for your dog, shared photos, and direct communication with potential adopters. 

Many rehoming websites also offer screening tools or guidance through this process. One trusted option is Rehome by Adopt a Pet, designed to make the transition safer and smoother for your dog.

Surrender to a shelter or rescue

Surrendering your dog to a shelter or rescue can be a responsible option when you’re unable to successfully rehome your pet. Many have networks of fosters, adoption programs, and resources designed to place dogs in safe, loving homes that match each dog’s specific needs. 

Although it can be emotional to surrender a pet, working with a trusted organization helps your dog get proper care, medical attention, and ultimately, a stable new family. While considering this option, look for shelters or rescues with good reputations, transparent policies, and strong adoption support.

Return them to the breeder, shelter, or rescue group

If your dog came from a breeder, shelter, or rescue group, returning them there is often one of the safest and most straightforward rehoming options. Many reputable organizations include return policies in their contracts, ensuring the dog can come back to them if circumstances change. This approach not only provides peace of mind, but also ensures your dog is placed with people who know their history and are committed to finding them a suitable new home. 

Be sure to disclose any information you have learned about your dog while they were in your care to help the breeder, rescue, or shelter find a good fit home.

Rehome to a trusted family member or friend

Rehoming your dog to a friend or family member allows you to place your pet with someone you know and trust. This arrangement makes it easier to ensure your dog will be cared for in a safe, loving environment — and you may even be able to stay in touch or visit. 

It’s still important to have open conversations about expectations, responsibilities, and your dog’s needs to make sure the match is a good long-term fit for everyone involved.

Commonly asked questions

What’s a rehoming fee for a dog?

A rehoming fee is charged by the current pet parent (or an organization) when adopting a dog into a new home. These predetermined fees can make sure the dog goes to a good home. They discourage impulse adoptions, people with bad intentions (who might use free dogs for resale, breeding, or other unsafe purposes), help cover some costs of the dog’s care (such as vaccinations, spay/neuter, or supplies), and show commitment from the adopter.

Is it cruel to rehome a dog?

Rehoming a dog can be an act of love when done responsibly. There are situations where a dog’s needs simply can’t be met in their current home. In those cases, finding a safe, stable home where a dog can thrive may be the kindest choice a pet parent can make. What matters most is how you rehome your dog: Be honest about the dog’s needs, carefully screen adopters, and when possible, work with trusted rescues or rehoming programs to ensure the pet’s safety and well-being.

References

Bir, Courtney, Kayla Pasteur, Nicole Widmar, and Candace Croney. “Pet Acquisition Trends and Veterinary Care Access in the US.” PLOS One 20, no. 7 (July 2, 2025). doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0325075.

Dolan, Emily, Jamie Scotto, Margaret Slater, and Emily Weiss. “Risk Factors for Dog Relinquishment to a Los Angeles Municipal Animal Shelter.” Animals 5, no. 4 (December 10, 2015): 1311–28. doi.org/10.3390/ani5040413.

Eagan, Bailey H., Emilia Gordon, and Alexandra Protopopova. “Reasons for Guardian-Relinquishment of Dogs to Shelters: Animal and Regional Predictors in British Columbia, Canada.” Frontiers in Veterinary Science 9 (April 14, 2022). doi.org/10.3389/fvets.2022.857634.

Hawes, Sloane M., Josephine M. Kerrigan, Tess Hupe, and Kevin N. Morris. “Factors Informing the Return of Adopted Dogs and Cats to an Animal Shelter.” Animals 10, no. 9 (September 3, 2020): 1573. doi.org/10.3390/ani10091573.

Kisley, Michael A., Esther J. Chung, and Hannah Levitt. “Investigating the Reasons behind Companion Animal Relinquishment: A Systematic Content Analysis of Shelter Records for Cats and Dogs, 2018–2023.” Animals 14, no. 17 (September 7, 2024): 2606. doi.org/10.3390/ani14172606.

Powell, Lauren, Deborah L. Duffy, Katherine A. Kruger, Brittany Watson, and James A. Serpell. “Relinquishing Owners Underestimate Their Dog’s Behavioral Problems: Deception or Lack of Knowledge?” Frontiers in Veterinary Science 8 (September 10, 2021). doi.org/10.3389/fvets.2021.734973.

Salman, Mo D., Jennifer Hutchison, Rebecca Ruch-Gallie, Lori Kogan, John C. New, Phillip H. Kass, and Janet M. Scarlett. “Behavioral Reasons for Relinquishment of Dogs and Cats to 12 Shelters.” Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science 3, no. 2 (April 2000): 93–106. doi.org/10.1207/s15327604jaws0302_2.

Singler, Emily. "Using Data to Decrease Pet Relinquishment." AAHA Newstat, November 1, 2024. www.aaha.org/newstat/publications/using-data-to-decrease-pet-relinquishment.