Is It Cruel to Rehome a Dog?

Have you recently adopted a dog and found yourself feeling overwhelmed and experiencing regret? Or maybe you’ve had your dog for a while, but changes in your life, or challenges with your dog’s behavior or health, have made it difficult to keep up with their care.

Support from a trainer, vet, dog walker, or friends and family can often make things more manageable. But if you’ve given it your best effort and things still aren’t improving, rehoming may be the kindest and most responsible choice.

This guide will help you navigate what to do when you’re feeling like you no longer want your dog, where to turn for support, and how to make a decision that’s best for you and your pup.

I adopted a dog, and now I regret it 

Bringing a dog home is a major commitment, and many people, especially first-time dog parents, start with high hopes and rosy expectations. But when reality doesn’t quite match that vision, it can lead to what’s called the “puppy blues,” a period of stress or regret after adoption. 

If you’re feeling this way, take a step back to reflect on what’s behind those emotions. 

• Are you struggling with feeling like you don’t have enough time or energy to meet your dog’s needs? 

• Are you feeling disconnected and unsure if this dog is the right match for you?

• Are you mourning the loss of freedom or spontaneity in your daily life?

• Do you feel unsupported by family or housemates?

• Is caring for a pet clashing with your job, travel plans, or living situation?

• Is your dog exhibiting behavior or health issues you weren’t prepared for?

Understanding the root of your regret can help you figure out what kind of support you need. Keep in mind: Feeling regret doesn’t necessarily mean you made the wrong decision. It could just be part of the adjustment period that comes with any major life change. Give yourself space to settle in, and consider if the situation could improve with the right help.

Explore options to address your concerns 

Before deciding to rehome your dog, it’s worth trying a few strategies that could ease the challenges you’re facing.

Take your dog to the vet for a checkup 

If your dog is showing signs of behavioral issues, like anxiety or aggression, it’s a good idea to start with a vet visit. Sometimes, these behaviors are linked to underlying pain, illness, or discomfort. A full checkup can help rule out any medical causes. 

Talk to a dog behaviorist

If your dog has a clean bill of health but is exhibiting challenging behaviors, working with a certified dog behaviorist is a smart next step. These professionals specialize in understanding why dogs behave the way they do and can develop a personalized plan to modify that behavior in a humane, effective way.

Hire a dog trainer

For issues such as pulling on a leash, jumping, or not listening, a professional dog trainer can be a helpful resource. Trainers can teach you and your dog new skills to improve communication and reduce frustration on both sides.

Look into dog-walking services

If you’re having a hard time keeping up with your dog’s need for daily walks, hiring a dog walker can make a big difference. Even hiring someone to take your dog on a few walks a week can give you some much-needed breathing room.

Lean on your support system

If you have friends, family, or roommates who are willing to help with walks, supervision, feeding, or playtime, don’t hesitate to ask. Having an extra set of hands can lighten the load.

Try doggie daycare 

If your schedule is packed, doggie daycare can be a lifesaver. It gives you time to focus on work, tackle a busy to-do list, or just take a breather while your dog gets to play, socialize, and burn off energy in a safe, structured environment.

Seek assistance for pet food and medical bills 

If financial stress is overwhelming you, look into resources that offer help with pet food, supplies, or vet care. Refer to our guide on how to get help with your pet-related bills.

Related article

Pet Food Assistance: How to Get Free Pet Food

Having financial issues doesn’t mean you have to give up your pet. Here’s how to get help.

Add more mental enrichment

Sometimes, problem behaviors stem from boredom. Enrichment toys, puzzle feeders, and scent-based games can satisfy your dog’s need for mental stimulation. While your dog is busy working through a puzzle game, you get a little time to yourself.

Give it a bit more time 

The adjustment period after adoption can be challenging for both you and your new pup. Keep the 3-3-3 rule in mind: It typically takes three days for a dog to start decompressing, three weeks for them to begin settling into a routine, and three months (or more) to truly feel at home and show their full personality. During this time, your dog is learning what’s safe, where they fit in, and how to trust you. 

If you’re not dealing with an urgent situation, giving your dog more time and patience can go a long way. As you both adjust, your bond may strengthen. What once felt overwhelming could start to feel more manageable and rewarding.

Is it cruel to rehome a dog?

When done responsibly and with the dog’s best interest in mind, rehoming is not cruel. 

Dogs need environments where their physical, emotional, and social needs are met. If you’ve reached a point where you truly can’t provide the time, care, or stability your dog needs, finding them a home that can may be the kindest choice.

Letting go can feel sad and defeating, but sometimes it’s the most selfless decision you can make for an animal you care about.

How to rehome a dog

If you’ve explored your options and feel that rehoming is the most responsible decision, the next step is to find your dog a safe, loving new home. Here’s how to approach that process.

Using a reputable pet-rehoming site that supports rehoming and adoptions, such as Rehome by Adopt a Pet, is a great place to get started. The process is straightforward:

1. You create a profile for your dog

2. Review applications from interested adopters

3. Meet your top picks

4. Finalize the adoption once you’ve found the right match

How not to rehome your dog

It’s just as important to know what not to do when rehoming your dog. Even with good intentions, certain approaches can put your dog at risk. Here are some common mistakes to avoid.

Don’t give your dog away “free to a good home” online

Although giving away your dog for free might seem like a kind gesture, this can unfortunately attract people with bad intentions. Some people seek out free pets for unethical or unsafe purposes. Requesting a reasonable rehoming fee (even just $50) and carefully screening potential adopters improves the likelihood your dog will end up in a safe, responsible home.

Don’t rehome in a rush

Rushing the process can lead to poor matches. Take time to evaluate potential adopters, ask the right questions, and make sure they’re prepared to take on the responsibility of caring for your dog.

Don’t misrepresent your dog

Be honest about your dog’s behavior, medical needs, energy level, and personality. Hiding challenges might make it easier to find a home quickly, but it can set up your dog and their new family for failure. The more accurate the information, the better your dog’s chances are of being matched with a home that can truly support them.

Try to avoid surrendering your dog to a shelter 

Surrendering your dog to a shelter (even the one you originally adopted from) should be considered a last resort. Although many shelters do their best to care for each animal they take in, they’re often overwhelmed and may lack the time, space, or resources to give each dog the attention they need. In overcrowded facilities, there’s a risk they may be euthanized, especially if the dog has behavioral challenges. 

Never abandon your dog 

No matter how overwhelmed you feel, abandoning your dog is never an acceptable option. Leaving a dog on the street, in a park, or even outside a shelter after hours puts them at serious risk of injury, illness, or death. It’s also illegal in many areas and can result in criminal charges.

Do You Need to Rehome Your Pet?

If you’re considering finding a new home for your pet, check out Rehome by Adopt a Pet. It’s a safe, simple program that helps pet parents safely rehome their pets. So pets can find new loving homes without entering a shelter.

Explore options

Commonly asked questions 

How do you rehome a dog quickly?

The safest ways to rehome your dog quickly include reaching out to friends or family, using a reputable platform like Rehome by Adopt a Pet, and contacting the original shelter or rescue you adopted them from. But avoid rushing the process. Always screen adopters carefully to find a good match.

How do you rehome a dog who bites? 

Rehoming a dog who bites should be done carefully and with full transparency. The dog needs to go to someone experienced in addressing behavioral issues, such as a trainer or behaviorist. 

How do dogs cope with being rehomed?

Dogs often need time to adjust to a new environment and may seem anxious or withdrawn at first. But with consistency, patience, and care, most dogs settle in and go on to build strong bonds with their new families.

How do I know if I’m making the right decision?

Take an honest look at whether or not your dog’s physical and emotional needs are being met, and if you’ve actually tried to work through the challenges. If you’re unable to provide the care they need, rehoming may be the most compassionate choice for both of you.

References 

Lowrey, Sassafras. “Rehoming a Dog Responsibly: What to Know.” American Kennel Club, www.akc.org/expert-advice/lifestyle/rehoming-dog-responsibly-know.

“Tips for Rehoming Your Pet - East Bay SPCA.” East Bay SPCA, eastbayspca.org/resources/rehome-surrender-a-pet/tips-for-rehoming-your-pet.